Couple Arrested For Not Allowing Expensive Medical Tests On Baby Daughter

Fact checked

A couple are facing child abuse charges in the U.S. for refusing costly medical tests on their daughter

Authorities booked the Indian origin couple for child neglect and abuse after they dared to questioned why their six month old daughter had to undergo expensive tests.

They were granted bail on Thursday after being arrested and jailed but their child and her twin brother will remain under the custody of Child Protective Services.

NDTV reports: They were arrested last Friday, weeks after they took her to a hospital at Broward County in Florida with a swollen left arm. However, Child Protective Services will continue to have custody of their six-month-old babies, with no parental access.

Authorities booked them for child neglect and abuse after the couple from Tamil Nadu allegedly questioned why the girl had to undergo expensive tests at the medical establishment and attempted to take the child from the hospital against doctors’ advice.

The couple, Prakash Settu and Mala Paneerselvam, was earlier sent to a prison in Fort Lauderdale with the bail amount set at $200,000. A person familiar with the matter told NDTV on Thursday that “the bail amount was ultimately reduced to $30,000, and the couple released just a few hours ago”.

The baby, Himisha, and her twin brother were taken away from them by Child Protective Services a few weeks ago.

Friends of the family, who deny the allegations levelled against the couple, have organised an online fundraiser to help them wage a legal battle against the US authorities. “Separating newborn twins from biological parents is a sin. Let them hand over them to me, as a grandmother. I’d take care of them,” Ms Paneerselvam’s mother, Malika, told NDTV.

A close friend of the couple claimed that they had enquired about the need for expensive medical tests at each stage of the treatment only because they could not afford them. “Their insurance did not cover all of them. This was misconstrued as neglect,” the friend said.

The Ministry of External Affairs is also in touch with US authorities in this regard.

However, a report from Florida Health Children’s Medical Services, Broward County, in NDTV’s possession alleges that Mr Settu and his wife refused to let hospital staffers conduct a “skeletal survey” and even tried to take their daughter away. The hospital viewed this as a case of possible child neglect and summoned Child Protective Services agents to the scene.

The US consulate, when contacted, stated that they will not be able to comment on “individual cases of investigation”.


  1. there is no change without revolution said Lenin ,And look what the democratic revolution has morphed into over its progress and its coming out celebrations particularly since the 1960s and the destruction of Christian society and values really ramped up and drugs sex rock n roll became the new world orders mantra .We now live in a corporate cannibals , from the lyrics of Grace Jones, Paradise ,”DIGITAL CRIMINALS”and the rule of law is the moral authority of the First ever Jesuit Pope

  2. Obviously, this is a violation of the parent’s Constitutional rights. As ppl, we have the right to NOT have medical or other procedures done if we chose. The state is not our owner or guardian. Time to get back to the real laws of this land – the US Constitution and Bill of Rights. Got to purge our entire nation of those who are against both documents and our God-given rights. Thank God for Prez Trump and team!

  3. It didn’t specify the circumstances why they wanted to do further tests; but if she was abused, they had reasons for testing her.

  4. This will serve as a good example why health care should be available to anyone free of charge paid for by government funded by taxpayers, it also ensures that people will go looking for treatment when required instead of having to decline on the basis of astronomical cost involved due to operating on a for profit basis.

    People should not be forced into private healthcare, however that appears to be the case.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.