Germany’s Top Court Rules Freedom Of Speech Doesn’t Cover Holocaust Denial

Fact checked

An 89 year old woman lost an appeal against her prison sentence for having a different view on history

German holocaust denier Ursula Haverbeck, lost her appeal before Germany’s highest court, which reaffirmed that constitutional free speech guarantees do not cover Holocaust denial.

The court ruled that denying the mass murder of Jews during Nazi Germany is not covered by the right to free speech and actually “threatens public peace”.

Dubber the ‘Nazi grandma’, Haverbeck started her latest prison term in May for saying that Nazi Germany’s mass murder of millions of Jews and others was “only a belief” and that Auschwitz was “not historically proven” to have been a death camp.

The Telegraph reports: The 89-year old went to Germany’s constitutional court to appeal her sentence, claiming that her statements fall under the country’s right to free speech, which is protected by law.

But in their ruling, the high court judges found that the right to free speech does not protect the denial of the Holocaust.

“The dissemination of untrue and deliberately false statements of fact can not contribute to the development of public opinion and thus do not fall in the remits of protection for free speech”, the judges wrote in a statement.

“The denial of the Nazi genocide goes beyond the limits of the peacefulness of public debate and threatens public peace,” they added.

Haverbeck has a long history of support for the former Nazi regime and co-founded a now-banned right wing ‘education center’ called Collegium Humanum with her late husband Werner Georg Haverbeck, a former Nazi party member.

Her articles denying the Holocaust were published in right-wing magazine Stimme des Reiches (Voice of the Empire).

Haverbeck has received several convictions from a range of German courts for her claims that the systematic mass murder of millions of Jews and other persecuted groups during Germany’s Nazi regime did not take place.

On one occasion she was convicted for calling the Holocaust “the biggest and longest-lasting lie in history.”

Niamh Harris
I am an alternative health practitioner interested in helping others reach their maximum potential.