MI6 Paralyzed As CIA Exposed In Senate Report

Fact checked by The People's Voice Community

The Fox, The Cat, And The Senate Report

There is an old Aesop’s fable called “The Fox and The Cat” [1] which comes to mind when viewing the CIA and MI6 when it comes to the recent controversial senate report.  It goes something like this:

A fox was boasting to a cat of its

clever devices for escaping its enemies.

“I have a whole bag of tricks,” he said,

“which contains a hundred ways of escaping my enemies.”

“I have only one,” said the cat.

“But I can generally manage with that.”

Just at that moment they heard the cry of a

pack of hounds coming towards them, and the cat

immediately scampered up a tree and hid herself in the boughs.

“This is my plan,” said the cat. “What are you going to do?”

“This is my plan,” said the cat. “What are you going to do?”

The fox thought first of one way, then of another,

and while he was debating, the hounds came nearer and nearer,

and at last the fox in his confusion was caught up by the hounds

and soon killed by the huntsmen.

Miss Puss, who had been looking on, said,

“Better one safe way than a hundred on which you cannot reckon.”

Americans Tired of Lies

senate report

The recent US Senate Intelligence Committee Report [2], which revealed what many Americans already expected: the CIA tortures and they torture to the point of agony.  After the initial shock of the details of torture methods is overcome, one glaring fact, as stated by the senate report is that torture accomplishes nothing.

Now, back to our fable above.  Many sources are reporting that MI6 is feeling temporarily paralyzed as they know in the next few days, the 5,000 plus page report will be read, and in those pages are likely connections to the horrific accounts described within.  MI6 has suddenly become the fox, while the CIA has scurried up a tree.

A report in The Independent titled “CIA torture report: So when will Britain come clean about its role?” [3] by Geoffrey Robertson sums it up pretty well in one sentence:

Where the CIA leads, MI6 usually follows. – Geoffrey Robertson

MI6 Bracing For The Backlash?


In the same report, reprinted below, journalist Robertson makes many parables between the CIA and MI6 as well as notates the differences – the main being the absolute secrecy under which MI6 operates comparatively to the CIA.  However, where there is smoke, as they say, there is fire, and Robertson makes a poignant statement that sums up MI6’s current helpless state from the senate report:

Certainly, among the 5,500 unpublished pages in this Report, will be found details of MI6 collaboration in CIA torture. – Geoffrey Robertson

Robertson’s report is a must read, as it gives insight to what we may expect from MI6 in the coming days.

The CIA and MI6 Naked and Exposed


From Robertson’s article in The Independent:  The most remarkable thing about the US Senate Intelligence Committee Report is that it was published at all – a reproach incidentally, to the secrecy in which British politicians swathe MI6.

Two of the Report’s findings will make a permanent contribution to anti-terror discourse: the fact that torture never produces crucial intelligence and the fact that intelligence agencies lie bare-facedly to their media acolytes, to the public and even on oath.

There is, of course, disappointment that most of the Report has been redacted – including details of British connivance and participation in the CIA torture programme.

There is regret that President Obama has declined to prosecute those lawyers and operatives who broke the law during the Bush years. But his determination to at least to have US brutality exposed and renounced will be a defining legacy of his presidency.

“Exploiting Individual Phobias”


Many of the torture techniques we know from revelations during his first term – the water-boarding, the euphemisms: “exploiting individual phobias” means setting Alsatians to sniff the genitals of suspects; “adjusting temperature” means subjecting them to sub-zero freezing; “dietary manipulation” means temporary starvation and so on.

Now the Report informs us that these techniques were often “far more brutal” than hitherto admitted. For example, “stress positions” could mean hanging a suspect in shackles for 180 hours.

They were designed to cause physical and mental harm and the White House’s lickspittle lawyers twisted the law so that their clients could be told what they wanted to hear, i.e. that this was not torture, merely “degrading treatment”. Regrettably, these lawyers will not be prosecuted, as they should be, for aiding and abetting torture.

Morally, the buck stops with Bush and Rumsfeld, although the only verdict they will face is that of history. The Senate Report makes a “guilty” verdict even more likely.

Torture Doesn’t Work, But Tea Does?


The great importance of the Report is to refute the claim, made or believed by every torturer, that brutality “gets results”. The Report states authoritatively that at no time did “coercive interrogation techniques” help to expose imminent threats or achieve successes and that the CIA has incorrigibly lied about this (and is still lying, to judge from its reaction to the Report).

These findings hit the torture lobby where it hurts. No longer can it trot out the unreal “ticking time bomb” hypothetical – fanatics who know where the bomb is hidden stay silent because they welcome death as martyrdom, whilst those who are pain-wracked supply false information which distracts the police while time ticks away. Interrogators always do better by offering money, or freedom – one of the most important leads to Bin Laden was elicited by offering a cup of tea.

Where The CIA Leads, MI6 Usually Follows


The exposure of how spooks regularly lie also repays study: where the CIA leads, MI6 usually follows, although political cowardice in Britain generally allows our intelligence services to stay silent.

Certainly, among the 5,500 unpublished pages in this Report, will be found details of MI6 collaboration in CIA torture. They are unpublished because the British government has invoked a protocol that allies must not spill each other’s secrets.

Mr Cameron, if he shares the gumption and integrity displayed by President Obama, should call for these redacted passages and publish them.

Britain, too, should publicly reject conduct up with which we should not put.



[1] http://www.pitt.edu/~dash/type0105.html#grimm

[2] Senate Report

[3] http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/cia-torture-report-so-when-will-britain-come-clean-about-its-role-9913756.html

Royce Christyn
About Royce Christyn 3440 Articles
Documentarian, Writer, Producer, Director, Author.